The logic is that's your rival and he has a dismal record against them. The logic is there's been at least a half dozen times in Gundy's career where OSU was better and lost (and only 1 time where the opposite happened). The logic is Gundy, as great as he's historically been for OSU, is worse against OU than 4 other OSU coaches.
OU through the Stoops years had an historically great run. So it's not so much the win/loss outcome in Bedlam games. It is the way Gundy has coached in those games. He mostly coaches scared. He's okay with losing that one and it shows.
Reading comprehension is important: what I said was "if Gundy does a Gundy," meaning if he punts from OU's 39 yard line while down 3 scores, then I'll definitely call for his head. Heck, even if the Pokes win, if Gundy makes those kinds of calls, I'll be critical. But, if he pulls out all stops and is aggressive (like going for two to win it), and the Cowboys still lose, then I won't like the loss, but I won't place the blame on Gundy.