The execution of both was poor
Oh yeah, that's probably the cause
I ran this entire thread through grok and it says my joke did "moderately well" within the context of the rivalry. The sarcasm was well executed and "appropriately biting".
Fit Within the Thread: The joke aligns well with Midnight Toker’s overall posting style, which blends earnest OU defense with sarcastic deflections of criticism.
- Context of the Joke: KK10’s post (#144) suggests that OU should focus on preparing backup quarterback Hawkins because starter John “Moneyline” Mateer might become ineligible, implying a gambling issue (likely a playful jab, as KK10 later admits they were “not even 1/2 serious”). Midnight Toker responds in post #146 by dismissing the ineligibility claim as unprovable and then adds the line, “word around the trailer park is that Hawkins has looked real good in camp.” The “trailer park” reference is a deliberate play on a stereotype often used in the OU-OSU rivalry, where OSU fans mock OU fans as “trailer park dwellers” to imply they’re less sophisticated or lower-class. Midnight Toker flips this stereotype, using it sarcastically to suggest that even in this derogatory context, OU’s backup quarterback is performing well.
- Did the Joke Land?: The joke lands moderately well within the context of the thread’s rivalry-driven banter. The “trailer park” line is a clever nod to the OU-OSU fanbase dynamic, showing Midnight Toker’s awareness of the stereotype and their willingness to lean into it for humor. It’s a subtle jab back at KK10, implying that even if OU fans are stereotyped as “trailer park” residents, they still have positive news about their team.
Sarcasm Level: The sarcasm is well-executed and appropriately biting for the thread’s tone. The “trailer park” line is deadpan enough to fit Midnight Toker’s self-described “deadpan delivery” (post #151), and it cleverly subverts the stereotype by embracing it without defensiveness. The sarcasm is clear to those familiar with the OU-OSU rivalry, but it might be too niche for a broader audience, as it relies on understanding the specific fanbase insult.
Was It Funny or Dumb?: The joke is funny in a subtle, rivalry-specific way. It’s not laugh-out-loud hilarious but earns points for being a quick, contextually relevant jab that plays on the OSU fanbase’s stereotype without being overly aggressive. It’s a smart move by Midnight Toker to deflect KK10’s trolling while staying in the spirit of the thread’s banter.
Final Thoughts on the JokeThe “trailer park” joke is a clever, moderately funny quip that effectively plays on the OU-OSU rivalry’s stereotypes. Its sarcasm is well-calibrated, fitting Midnight Toker’s deadpan style, but its impact is limited by the thread’s hostile tone and KK10’s dismissive response. It’s not dumb—it’s a smart, rivalry-specific jab—but it’s not a showstopper either, as it gets lost in the thread’s broader antagonism. The joke showcases Midnight Toker’s ability to hold their own in a hostile environment, but its success is tempered by the lack of engagement from other posters.