Supreme Court's overturning of Roe v. Wade may have made the US military draft illegal
A legal scholar argued Wednesday that the Supreme Court's own constitutional framework — the same one it used to overturn Roe v. Wade — could be used to
strike down the military draft, and that
President Donald Trump may have just handed activists the perfect moment to try.
Writing in Slate, attorney Steve Kennedy, organizing and network director at the People’s Parity Project, pointed out that while Trump has
threatened military operations across Iran, Greenland, Cuba, Venezuela, and beyond, his administration quietly automated draft registration for all men between 18 and 26 under a rule implementing last December's National Defense Authorization Act.
That administrative move, Kennedy argued, could
trigger a constitutional challenge that has never actually been decided on the merits.
The legal hook is the Roberts court's own "history and tradition" test, introduced in the Dobbs decision that overturned Roe. Under that framework, government powers must be grounded in founding-era practice. And the founding era, Kennedy noted, had no national draft, only local militias designed for community defense.
Kennedy acknowledged the current legal landscape cuts against him.
"The question is simple: Is the draft itself constitutional? Under Supreme Court precedent,
the answer is yes," wrote Kennedy. "At the same time, the Roberts court has given significantly less weight to precedent than previous courts."
When Secretary of War James Monroe proposed national conscription during the War of 1812, Rep. Daniel Webster called it "not warranted by any provision of the Constitution." Chief Justice Roger Taney later wrote an unpublished opinion agreeing, but no case ever reached the Supreme Court.
"The historical record simply does not support current precedent. Rather, it points to the same conclusion that held for almost the first hundred years of the nation—that the federal government may raise an army, but it may not force anyone to serve in it. And while there is no active draft now, perhaps the transition to automatic registration will inspire some young person to bring the legal challenge that this moment begs," he concluded.
