View attachment 16885
I read the essay. I read the assignment. I read the TA's response to the essay.
My objective response as both a professor and former department chair, and as a conservative Christian, though I no longer identify as an evangelical as this student clearly does:
1. The student did not complete the assignment as the essay written. The essay was a statement of beliefs, but not a proper response to the research article.
2. The TA was correct in not awarding any points for the assignment. There was a rubric. You read the essay and check off boxes on the rubric. The essay failed the rubric. As I read the essay and the rubric the essay earned a zero.
3. Where the TA made an error, perhaps, was in using the term "offensive". The TA would have been better served to use completely neutral language.
4. I do not see what the terminable offense here was. As her department chair I would have had to support the TA completely.