I was at the 1988 OSU-OU game and it was more about the bogus roughing call, when it was actually the OU guy pulling the OSU guy out of bounds. Just watched the TV replay of it for the first time ever and even the announcers said it was a bad call.
I have never heard anyone blame Gundy for the 4th down play and Parker dropping the ball.
It was 1989 that everyone realized Gundy was a game manager. Playing with Thurman Thomas, Barry Sanders, and Hart Lee Dykes has a way of making the QB look good.
1989 went 4-7 and started the season with a loss at Tulsa and capped it off with a home loss to Iowa State.
Gundy was a good QB, but he wasn't great. OSU didn't have very many good QB's in the following years.